After testing both platforms extensively myself, I think Printify is the best choice overall. It offers access to more unique products (like custom coffee), advanced AI-powered design tools, and a huge range of integration options.
Prodigi does have its benefits though, from it’s easy to use interface, to its affordable pricing, and eco-friendly approach to production.
So, how do you make the right choice? This complete comparison guide will tell you everything you need to know.
The Quick Verdict
Printify beat Prodigi in most of the tests I conducted. It has stronger design tools (including an AI image generator), more unique product options, more printing options, and gives you access to a wider range of sales channels.
There’s even a free pop-up store tool.
Prodigi does excel in some areas, though. It offers access to very cost-effective products, is extremely easy to use, and specializes in sustainable print on demand.
Prodigi Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Strong commitment to sustainable production and fulfillment
- Over 500,000 customizable products
- Easy-to-use interface (ideal for beginners)
- Fast production times (24-48 hours for most products)
- Straightforward mockup generator
Cons:
- The design tools are relatively basic
- No premium plans with extra perks
- Fewer sales channels
Printify Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lots of unique products, including beauty items and coffee
- Integrations with dozens of sales channels
- Huge range of global manufacturers
- Great AI-powered design tools
- Various branding and customization options
- Free pop-up store creator
Cons:
- Product pricing and quality can vary
- Some manufacturers have slower production times
Prodigi vs Printify: Core Features
On the surface, Prodigi and Printify seem pretty similar. They both give you instant access to hundreds of customizable products, design tools, mockup generators, and global fulfillment services.
They also both integrate with ecommerce platforms and marketplaces (though Printify has more options to choose from).
However, I noticed some key differences when testing these platforms myself.
Product Variety and Quality
Let’s start with one of the most important factors to consider when choosing a POD platform – the products.
Prodigi seems to offer more customizable products than Printify, telling companies they can add designs to over 500,000 different items. But there aren’t many unique options to choose from.
Printify gives you more than 900 products to customize, including options you won’t find anywhere else, like branded coffee and cosmetics.
Prodigi also doesn’t seem to have as many advanced printing options, like all-over-print and sublimation – while Printify does.
One other point to note is that Prodigi specializes in sustainable and eco-friendly printing and production.
They source sustainable materials, and work with local distribution companies to minimize your carbon footprint.
However, the same could be said for Printify. They also offer sustainable products, and work with suppliers worldwide.
From a product quality perspective, both companies have their pros and cons. They both follow strict quality assurance measures and use cutting-edge technology, alongside high quality materials.
However, Prodigi has earned a few negative reviews for its printing clarity in the past.
Printify, on the other hand, does have a reasonably good reputation, but since the company outsources printing to hundreds of different global manufacturers, it’s difficult to know exactly what you’re going to get.
I’d definitely recommend reading the reviews for each Printify vendor, and ordering samples before you choose your supplier.
Design and Customization Options
As I mentioned above, Printify seems to offer more ways to customize your products, with things like “all-over-print”.
They also give you more ways to showcase your brand on the items you create, with custom tags, packing slips, and other elements. I couldn’t find many branding options on Prodigi.
When it comes to the design experience, there’s no doubt that Printify is the superior platform. While I do like how convenient and straightforward Prodigi’s design tools and mockup generator are, Printify is really on the cutting edge of the POD market.
It offers access to AI-powered image generators, that can create unique graphics for you based on prompts.
Plus, you get access to a huge range of free resources and assets you can add to your designs. Printify’s mockup generator is fantastic too, allowing you to create images of your products in “lifestyle” settings, so they really stand out on your website.
Plus, if you need help with design, Printify offers a range of services, including their “Experts Program”, to help match you to designers and other specialists.
Integrations and Sales Channels
Printify wins again from a sales channel and scalability perspective – hands down. Prodigi does integrate with some of the top platforms, like Shopify, WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce, and Etsy.
However, Printify integrates with even more channels. You can connect the platform to your Walmart or Ebay storefront, TikTok Shop, and PrestaShop.
Printify also allows you to sell directly through their platform without using an integration. You can create a Printify pop-up store for free, and share a customized link with your shoppers.
Though this “pop-up store” is pretty basic, it’s a great way to start selling for free, without having to manage all of the headaches of building and managing your own site.
Of course, if you are using the pop-up store service, I’d definitely recommend branching out to a few additional sales channels as soon as possible. That’ll help you build a more memorable brand, and boost your chances of increased sales.
Ease of Use and Customer Support
In my opinion, there’s not a huge amount of difference between Printify and Prodigi when it comes to ease of use.
Both platforms are extremely straightforward and designed for beginners. You’ll have no problem signing up for an account and creating designs.
Printify is a bit more intuitive, with its flexible dashboard for tracking orders, AI capabilities in its design tools, and it’s step-by-step tool tips.
However, since you can do a lot more with Printify than Prodigi, you might spend a little longer learning how everything works.
From a customer support perspective, both companies offer access to tons of self-help resources like videos, blogs, and tutorials.
I do think Printify’s blog page is a lot more impressive, though. Printify also offers direct customer support through chat and email.
The only downside is that the manufacturers you work with through the platform don’t always respond quickly to questions.
Prodigi offers customer support mainly through email, and from what I can tell, you might have to wait a little longer to get a response, particularly during busy periods.
Prodigi vs Printify: Pricing and Fees
Now, let’s look at pricing. First, in terms of product fees, Printify and Prodigi are pretty similar. Both offer access to a range of affordable items, although the pricing can vary on Printify depending on the manufacturer you choose.
Both companies also allow users to get started for free. There are no limitations on the free plans, and you can create as many products as you like.
However, Printify does offer some “premium” plan options, which are worthwhile, in my opinion, for scaling companies.
The Premium plan for $24.99 per month (paid annually), allows you to create up to 10 stores, and gives you up to 20% discounts on all products – which seriously boosts your profit margins.
Plus, there’s an Enterprise plan with bigger discounts for the biggest companies. You can also pay for extra services from Printify, like web design support, and express delivery.
I honestly think the premium plans give Printify an edge over Prodigi, as they can save you a lot of money as you start to sell more products.
Prodigi vs Printify: The Verdict
Simply put, Printify outperforms Prodigi in virtually every area.
While Prodigi does offer some great eco-friendly options for sustainable companies, and access to a wide range of products, it can’t compete with Printify’s amazing design tools, or unique product options.
Printify also gives you more opportunities to sell through various channels (including your own free pop-up shop). Plus, it’s premium plans can help you to save money as your business scales.
